Table of Contents
During the normal 3-phase separation process in a disc-stack centrifuge, the heavy phase (typically water) forms a liquid seal around the periphery of the bowl.
Under certain conditions, the light phase pushes out the heavy phase and escapes through the heavy phase outlet. This operating condition is known as Liquid Seal Break or Break-Over.
This article will discuss the common causes of liquid seal breaking and the respective corrective measure for each of these causes.
A liquid seal break and breakover are the same condition in disc-stack centrifuge operation. These terms refer to the condition during which the light phase of the separating liquid ‘breakover’ or ‘breaks the heavy phase liquid seal’ and comes out through the heavy phase outlet.
The following is a list of causes causing a ‘liquid seal break’ or breakover condition during the operation of disc-stack centrifuges. Corrective measures to fix the breakover for each of the causes are also mentioned in this article.
The gravity disc in the centrifuge bowl regulates the oil-water interface within the centrifuge. For best separation results, the oil-water interface should be closest to the bowl periphery without breaking the water seal.
This interface positioning allows maximum g-force exerted by the rotation to act on the separation interface (shown below).
A gravity disc with a larger hole diameter than the correct size (as determined by the nomogram) pushes the oil-water interface radially outwards. This incorrect interface positioning causes the light phase (oil) to be outside the top disc.
The light phase can now exit the centrifuge bowl through the heavy phase passage and out through the heavy phase outlet. This, by definition, is a broken liquid seal.
In this case, the process fluid (oil) comes out of the heavy phase (water) side causing fluid loss, which is highly undesirable.
The correct gravity disc with a smaller diameter hole (as indicated by the nomogram) will prevent the liquid seal from breaking. Therefore using the gravity disc with a smaller hole diameter will remedy this cause of liquid seal breaking or breakover.
The nomogram defines the correct gravity disc based on the specific gravity of the process fluid at a specific temperature. If the process fluid is not at the appropriate temperature, the gravity disc installed in the centrifuge bowl may cause the fluid interface to move radially outward beyond the top disc.
Under this condition, the light phase will exit the bowl through the heavy phase outlet (as explained above), causing a liquid seal break.
Maintaining the process fluid at the correct operating temperature throughout the process will prevent the liquid seal from breaking.
The centrifuge bowl size limits the amount of fluid of a given viscosity to pass through the disc stack. If the process fluid flow rate exceeds the bowl’s capacity, the process fluid will push the liquid seal out of the bowl. Subsequently, the light phase will escape the bowl through the heavy phase outlet causing a liquid seal to break.
Reducing the process fluid flow rate will allow the light phase through the disc stack and ensure proper separation.
In most centrifuge systems, a regulating valve is provided on the light phase outlet pipe to apply back pressure for optimum separation. If the light phase outlet valve is accidentally closed, the light phase fluid cannot exit the bowl through its designed outlet.
The light phase fluid will then push out the heavy phase liquid seal and exit the bowl through the heavy phase outlet. This causes a breakover.
The light phase outlet valve should be checked and opened if it is closed. A pressure sensor on the light phase outlet can be installed to detect excessive pressure on the light phase outlet to activate an alarm and prevent this from causing a breakover.
The first step during the startup of a disc-stack centrifuge is the bowl’s priming with the heavy phase liquid, which is often water. The centrifuge bowl should be fed with priming liquid till the heavy phase liquid comes out through the heavy phase outlet.
This heavy fluid exiting the centrifuge bowl indicates that the bowl’s heavy phase space is filled with the priming liquid.
In an automated centrifuge system, the priming liquid is supplied to the bowl through a solenoid valve operated by a timer. If the water pressure or flow changes, the allocated time may not be sufficient to fill the bowl with an adequate amount of heavy-phase liquid.
In such cases, the light phase liquid will displace the heavy phase liquid and break the liquid seal.
The heavy phase’s flow path goes from the outer bowl periphery, above the top disc, then under the gravity disc, then into the heavy phase chamber, and finally out of the bowl. A couple of sealing parts (gasket and O-Ring) prevent the heavy phase from leaking out of the bowl.
An O-ring situated under the gravity disc seals the interface between the gravity disc and the bowl hood. If this o-ring is damaged, the heavy phase will escape through this interface due to the high centrifugal force’s extremely high pressure.
This unintentional reduction in the heavy phase will cause the liquid seal to break.
Similarly, a flat gasket above the gravity disc seals the interface between the gravity disc and the small lock ring. If this gasket is damaged or torn, it will allow the liquid seal to escape causing a liquid seal to break.
These seals should be routinely checked and replaced (if damaged) to prevent breakover during operation.
Other disc-centrifuge articles of interest......
Disc Centrifuge Backpressure - Comprehensive Guide
9 Steps to Selecting & Buying the Right Industrial Centrifuge
Centrifuge RCF and RPM | Difference & RCF Calculation
Disadvantages of a Disc-Stack Centrifuge | Illustrated Guide
Difference Between Decanter & Disc Centrifuge | Technical Comparison
The nylon seal ring embedded in the bowl hood presses against the lip of the sliding piston to form the main bowl seal that prevents the process fluid from escaping the bowl during separation. The priming liquid (heavy phase) is adjacent to this seal between the nylon seal ring and the sliding piston.
If the nylon seal ring is worn out, it will allow the heavy phase (prime liquid) to escape the bowl. Similarly, if the mating lip seal on the sliding piston is damaged, gouged, or worn, it will have a similar effect. In either case, the unintentional exit of the prime liquid will cause the liquid seal to break.
The nylon seal ring is a sacrificial part and should be replaced periodically before it wears and causes breakovers and other operating problems. The sliding piston sealing lip should also be checked regularly to avoid such issues.
Please read our article about top mechanical and fixes issues related to disc centrifuges.
In rare cases, if the process sludge builds up and enters the gap between the discs, it will block the light phase’s passage towards the center of the bowl. This disc blockage will cause the light phase to displace the heavy phase and, as a result, cause a breakover.
Under clogged disc stack conditions, the centrifuge should be stopped immediately and the disc stack thoroughly cleaned to remedy this cause of liquid seal break (breakover).
The centrifuge bowl speed generates the centrifugal force, which helps close the bowl through the operating water pressure under the sliding piston.
If the centrifuge bowl speed is low due to a mechanical or electrical fault, the operating water pressure is insufficient to close the bowl properly. An improperly closed bowl allows the priming water to exit the bowl, which causes the liquid seal to break or breakover.
The revolution counter on the centrifuge frame indicates the bowl speed to the operator. This speed should be periodically monitored to identify lower bowl speed.
Ensuring the centrifuge bowl is rotating at the designed speed will prevent low bowl speed from causing the liquid seal to break or breakover.
The disc centrifuge bowl is designed and manufactured very precisely. It is quite easy for an untrained operator to assemble the bowl incorrectly, which can cause some seals not to compress and seal adequately. For example, if the small lock ring is not tightened properly, the priming liquid (heavy phase) will escape the bowl through this inadequate seal causing the liquid seal to break.
If the bowl hood is not positioned correctly on the sliding piston, the resulting uneven seal between the nylon seal ring and sliding piston will cause the heavy phase to escape, causing the liquid seal to break.
Proper bowl assembly is critical to prevent breakover from occurring and for the safe and reliable operation of the disc-stack centrifuge.
A liquid seal break is detected by monitoring the fluid flowing out of the centrifuge. When the liquid seal breaks, it interrupts the fluid flow in the light phase outlet.
It also causes a sudden excess fluid flow through the heavy phase outlet. Mechanical or electronic devices can detect either of these indicators.
A liquid seal break is detected by monitoring the fluid flowing out of the centrifuge. When the liquid seal breaks, it interrupts the fluid flow in the light phase outlet.
It also causes a sudden excess fluid flow through the heavy phase outlet. Mechanical or electrical devices can detect either of these indicators.
The routing of the heavy phase outlet of the centrifuge is through a collection tank. This tank has a bottom drain with an adjustable valve. The valve allows the typical volume of heavy phase to drain through it.
But, in case of a liquid seal break, the excessive light phase volume accumulates in this tank. This accumulation of the light phase causes the tank level to rise and activates a level switch mounted in the tank.
The change of state of the level switch triggers an alarm in the centrifuge control system, which activates corrective action.
As mentioned above, the liquid seal break stops the flow in the centrifuge’s light phase outlet. During normal operation, a back-pressure valve maintains pressure in this line.
When a liquid seal break occurs, this pressure in the outlet line drop. A pressure sensor installed on this line senses the loss of pressure and thus detects liquid seal break.
Based on this trigger, the centrifuge control system stops the flow and activates an alarm.
The liquid seal breaking is a common problem most disc centrifuge operators are familiar with. The primary causes and remedies mentioned above should help correct the vast majority of liquid seal breaks occurring in disc centrifuges.
As seen above, most of these causes can be eliminated by periodic centrifuge maintenance and replacement of critical gaskets on the first sign of wear or damage.
by Sanjay Prabhu MSME
Engineering Manager, Dolphin Centrifuge