Dolphin Centrifuge

Ethanol Extraction Centrifuges: Technical Comparison

Table Of Contents

Ethanol Extraction Process

The use of solvents to extract CBD Oil and THC compounds from dry plant biomass is known as the ethanol extraction process. Depending on the type of compound desired, the process may vary, but alcohol in the form of ethanol is key to the extraction of cannabinoids.

An essential step in this process is separating the spent biomass from ethanol that has adsorbed the precious cannabinoids. The efficiency of this separation is critical to the efficiency of the extraction process.

Methods of Biomass and Ethanol Separation

There are several ways to separate the plant biomass from ethanol, starting with gravity separation, which is not feasible due to the time required for settling under gravity.

Another method is using filters, specifically filter presses to separate the biomass from the ethanol. Even though filter presses are in use by some CBD or THC producers, it is not an efficient method due to the labor involved to service the presses. Also, exposure to ethanol during the cleaning process is not conducive to the operator’s safety.

Industrial centrifuges are the most popular ethanol extractors due to their sealed designs and high separation efficiency. This article delves into the different types of ethanol extraction centrifuges and the pros and cons of each centrifuge type.

Types of Extraction Centrifuges

A centrifugal extractor is an industrial centrifuge that uses the centrifugal force generated by the biomass and ethanol mix rotation to affect the separation of the two phases. There are two types of industrial centrifuges, i.e., sedimentation and filtration type.

The CBD & THC producers use both these types of centrifuges in basket and decanter centrifuges, as described below. 

Basket Centrifuge (Washing Machine)

Basket Centrifuge for Ethanol Extraction
Basket Centrifuge for Ethanol Extraction

The image above shows the cross-section (left) and generic image (right) of a typical basket centrifuge also known as a washing machine centrifuge. 

As evident from the image, this is a filtration-type industrial centrifuge which means it uses the centrifugal force to push the liquid out of the basket mesh (perforations) to separate the ethanol from the biomass.

Decanter Centrifuge

Decanter Centrifuge for Ethanol Extraction
Decanter Centrifuge for Ethanol Extraction

The cross-section (left) and an Alfa Laval NX-418 decanter centrifuge (right) illustrate the construction and operation of a decanter centrifuge.

A decanter centrifuge is a solid-bowl centrifuge that falls in the sedimentation type industrial centrifuge category. This type of centrifuge uses a much higher centrifugal force to affect the separation of heavier biomass particles from the lighter ethanol.

For more details, please read our article differentiating the filtration type and sedimentation type centrifuges.

Comparison Of Specifications

Basket and decanter centrifuges differ in a variety of ways. In this section, we compare the typical specifications of these centrifuges.

The following table compares the essential characteristics that affect centrifugal performance.

Characteristic / SpecificationBasket Centrifuge
(Washing Machine)
Basket Centrifuge
Decanter Centrifuge

Ethanol Extraction Decanter Centrifuge
Comment
Axis of RotationVerticalHorizontal
Rotating Speed1,000 RPM4,000 RPM
G-Force~700 Gs3,100 Gs
Size (Typical)65″ L x 32″ W x 49″ H80″ L x 30″ W x 40″ H
Weight (Typical)1,450 Lbs2,500 Lbs
Basket / Bowl Size30” Radius x 15” (H)14” Radius x 60” (L)
Basket / Bowl ConstructionPerforated Sheet MetalSolid, Thick Wall
Material of ConstructionDifferent Grades of Stainless Steel316L Duplex Stainless Steel**Wetted Parts
Power230 V; 3-Phase230 / 460 V; 3-Phase
Drive Power7 HP15 HP
Processing Capacity~ 140 Lbs / Hour~ 600 Lbs/Hour
Operating Temperature-40 F to 85 F32 F* to 85 F*Process fluid cannot be below 32 F
Ethanol Recovery /Biomass Dryness~ 70%*~ 95%* (Adjustable)*Based on field process data

Operation

This section describes the operation of basket centrifuges and decanter centrifuges in ethanol extraction of CBD and THC cannabinoids production.

Basket Centrifuge (Washing Machine)

Ethanol Extraction Basket Centrifuge Cross Section
Ethanol Extraction Basket Centrifuge Cross Section

The operation of separating the hemp or cannabis biomass from ethanol using a basket centrifuge is as follows.

An operator stuffs a nylon bag with chopped, dry hemp or cannabis plant matter is placed in the centrifuge basket. The operator then closes the centrifuge and effectively seals the vessel from the atmosphere.

The operator then introduces clean ethanol to the eclosed basket chamber within the centrifuge vessel. The rotation of the loaded basket follows the ethanol addition. This rotation serves to circulate and agitate the ethanol within the hemp or cannabis plant matter.

The ethanol adsorbs the precious cannabinoids from the plant matter. After a predetermined period, an automatic valve allows the ethanol carrying the cannabinoids to exit the centrifuge. The constant rotation of the centrifuge causes a centrifugal force that spins out the ethanol from the plant matter, helping recover the maximum amount of ethanol.

The operator then opens the vessel to remove the spent biomass bag and replaces it with a bag containing fresh biomass. This cycle is repeated until the entire batch of biomass is processed.

This cannabinoid-loaded ethanol is filtered, winterized, and distilled to recover the cannabinoid concentrate.

Decanter Centrifuge

Ethanol Extraction Decanter Centrifuge Cross Section
Ethanol Extraction Decanter Centrifuge Cross Section

A decanter centrifuge has a solid wall bowl that rotates around a horizontal axis. An independently rotating scroll located within the bowl is concentric to the decanter bowl. The scroll connects to the bowl through a gearbox. This gearbox enables the scroll to rotate at a different speed than the bowl.

Alfa Laval Decanter NX-416 Stainless Steel Class 1 Div 2
Alfa Laval Decanter NX-416 Stainless Steel Class 1 Div 2

The chopped or pulverized, dry hemp or cannabis biomass is mixed with a predetermined volume of ethanol to form a slurry in a reactor vessel. An agitator mixes this slurry with the ethanol, which lets the ethanol adsorb the cannabinoids from the plant biomass.

Hemp Process Flow Diagram
Hemp Process Flow Diagram

A pump feeds this slurry to the rotating decanter through an inlet pipe. This pipe is stationary and is located at the center of the rotating bowl, delivering the ethanol biomass slurry.

The centrifugal force created by the rotation of the bowl pushes the heavier biomass particles towards the outer bowl wall, where they accumulate.

The rotating scroll pushes the separated biomass particles towards and ejected through the solid discharge ports located at one end of the bowl.

The relatively lighter ethanol floats above the solids and exits the bowl through the liquid exit ports located at the other end of the rotating bowl.

This separation is a continuous operation without stoppage. Thus, the decanter centrifuge can process the entire batch irrespective of the batch size or volume.

A decanter centrifuge has some unique mechanical adjustments that allow the operator to control the dryness of the biomass and the separated ethanol clarity.

Biomass Dryness Versus Residence Time

The biomass dryness is directly proportional to the centrifugal force and residence time in the centrifuge for the biomass & ethanol slurry.

In the washing machine type; open-top; low-RPM; low G-force (< 1000 Gs) centrifuge the residence time is adjustable and is typically in the range of 15 to 60 minutes.

Biomass Dryness Vs Ethanol Residence Time
Biomass Dryness Vs Ethanol Residence Time

A decanter centrifuge is a pass-through type centrifuge with a much higher centrifugal force (3,000+ Gs). The residence time in a decanter centrifuge is inversely proportional to the flow rate. In other words, a high flow rate causes reduced residence time and therefore, can be adjusted to a smaller degree by varying the flow rate.

The typical residence time in a decanter centrifuge is the range of 10 to 30 seconds.

The graph above shows the relationship between residence time and biomass dryness for these ethanol extraction centrifuges.

Operation Comparison Table

CharacteristicBasket CentrifugeDecanter CentrifugeComment
Process ModeBatchContinuous**Flowthrough Design
Labor Required?Yes*No*Operator Needed to Replace Biomass Bags
Premix Required?NoYes**Biomass Ethanol Premixed Slurry
Operator Exposure to EthanolYesNo**Fully Sealed Design w/ Continuous Flow
Spent Biomass RecoveryManual ExtractionContinuous Discharge
Adjustable Residence Time?YesYes**Limited Adjustment
Adjustable Ethanol Recovery?Yes*Yes*Processing Capacity Tradeoff
Adjustable Ethanol Clarity?No*Yes*Dependent on Bag Mesh Size
Consumable ItemsYes*None*Mesh Bags
DurabilityLimited*High*Frequent Stop/ Open/ Close/ Start Cycles
Duty CycleBatchContinuous
Service Life5~10 Years*30+ Years*Mechanical Durability, Field Data

Separating Efficiency

The separation efficiency is the smallest fluid or solid particle size effectively separated by the centrifuge. Stoke's law (shown below) defines the velocity of a solid particle as it travels through a fluid medium.


V = gRp2(ρp–ρ)/4.5μ

Where:
V = Terminal Velocity of Particle
Rp = Radius of Particle
g = Gravitation or G-Force
ρp= Density of Particle
ρ = Density of Fluid
µ  = Viscosity of Fluid

It is evident from the formula above that the separation efficiency (escape velocity) of a centrifuge is directly proportional to the centrifugal force (g) exerted by the centrifuge. In other words, the higher the centrifugal force, the smaller the particle size of separation.

The ability of a centrifuge to separate the fluid from the solid particles is a function of the centrifugal force and residence time. 

A centrifuge with a higher centrifugal force extracts more fluid from the solids than a centrifuge with a lower centrifugal force. Therefore, a higher g-force centrifuge is better in liquid extraction from the biomass than a lower g-force centrifuge.

The lower g-force centrifuge can remove the same amount of liquid but with a longer residence time. A longer residence time means a longer spin cycle in the basket centrifuge, which leads to lower production.

The percentage of ethanol recovered quoted for basket centrifuges is likely at an extended spin cycle time, adversely affecting the batch cycle time.

Summary of Pros and Cons

CriteriaBasket CentrifugeDecanter Centrifuge
Separation Efficiency~ 80%~ 95%
Processing ModeBatchContinuous
Processing Temperature-40 F to 85 F32 F to 85 F
Processing Capacity~ 2.5 GPM~ 20 GPM
LaborRequiredNot Required
Operator Exposure to Solvent (Ethanol)YesNo
Pre-Mixing RequiredNoYes
Small Scale ProcessingSuitableNot Suitable
Large Scale ProcessingNot SuitableSuitable
Downstream Filtration LoadMediumLow
Capital InvestmentMarginally LowerMarginally Higher
Operating Cost (Labor & Material)HighLow

This article is based on our considerable experience with centrifuges, especially as they apply to the ethanol extraction process. Visit our about us page to get to know more about Dolphin Centrifuge.

Contact

To get more details email us or call us on (248) 819-1732

Call Us Now
Copyright © 2020 Dolphin Marine & Industrial Centrifuges. All Rights Reserved.
crossmenuchevron-down