Table of Contents
An industrial centrifuge is a separation machine that uses centrifugal force to separate solids from liquids. A centrifuge exerts a centrifugal force that is thousands of times that of gravity.
This force causes the immediate separation of solids from liquids. And, in the case of immiscible liquids with different densities, it separates the fluids as well.
You can think of an industrial centrifuge as a scaled-up version of a lab centrifuge (test-tube) except at a much bigger scale with a flow-through design.
That means the separated solids and liquid(s) continuously exit the centrifuge.
Industrial centrifuges fall into two main categories: Filtration type and Sedimentation type.
A perforated media allows the fluid to exit the 'screen' bowl in a filtration centrifuge while retaining the solids. The separated liquid collects in the bowl casing and drains out.
A relatively lower rotational speed (lower centrifugal force) is adequate for filtration centrifuges.
They are suitable for separating large amounts of coarse solids from a liquid. An example would be the separation of crystallized sugar from syrup or a chemical precipitate from the supernatant.
There are various mechanisms to collect the separated solids. A description of some of these methods is in the following section.
There are a variety of filtration centrifuges.
A peeler centrifuge has cloth media, which the user 'peels' away with the solids. A basket centrifuge has a perforated 'basket' that retains the separated solids.
Pusher centrifuges have slotted bowls with an articulated pusher arm to 'push' the accumulated solids. A wire mesh 'screen' holds the solids in screening centrifuges.
A sedimentation centrifuge does not use a flow-through or perforated screen or media. This centrifuge uses a solid bowl, which is also known as a 'solid bowl centrifuge.'
The centrifugal force causes the denser solids to collect along the bowl wall. The lighter liquid thus separates from the solids. A liquid pathway allows the separated fluid to exit the bowl.
This 'solid bowl' feature adds an extra benefit to these sedimentation centrifuges.
The same centrifugal force also causes the differential settling of two immiscible liquids. In this case, the centrifuge separates all three phases, liquid, liquid, and solid. This separator is known as a 3-phase centrifuge.
The primary difference between filtration and sedimentation centrifuges is the bowl design. A filtration centrifuge has a pass-through bowl that allows the liquid to pass through and retain the solids. The sedimentation centrifuge has a solid bowl that uses differential settling to separate the solids from the liquid.
The following summarizes the other differences between these two types of centrifuges.
For more information, please read our detailed article on the technical difference between basket (filtration type) and decanter (sedimentation type) centrifuges.
The particle size efficiency of industrial centrifuges varies in size primarily due to the centrifuge design and other operating parameters such as flow rate, fluid viscosity, centrifugal force, etc.
The media or mesh perforation size in the filtration type centrifuge defines the particle size efficiency. Therefore, a filtration centrifuge separates particles bigger than the size of the perforation in the bowl wall or screen. This separation ability limits the application of filtration-type centrifuges to the preset size of the screen media or mesh size.
The sedimentation centrifuge, however, uses the centrifugal force for separation. The scroll pushes all the separated solids, regardless of size, out of the centrifuge bowl. Therefore, a solid bowl or sedimentation centrifuge can separate a wide range of particle sizes from the liquid.
In general, the particle size efficiency of the sedimentation centrifuge is higher than that of filtration-type centrifuges.
Sedimentation centrifuges use the difference between the specific gravity of the solids and liquids to affect separation. Therefore, these centrifuges exert a high centrifugal force (RCF) for effective separation.
Filtration-type centrifuges need a lower g-force to push the liquid through the bowl perforations.
Typically the sedimentation type centrifuges have centrifugal force from 3,000 Gs to 10,000 Gs, while the filtration type centrifuges have less than 2,000 Gs.
Read our article about the difference between RPM and RCF.
The sedimentation centrifuge ejects the separated solids continuously during sedimentation. A rotating scroll (auger) within the bowl pushes out the separated solids.
A filtration type centrifuge accumulates the separated solids, which a scraper scrapes out of the bowl periodically.
The flow-through bowl of the filtration centrifuge allows the liquid to flow out of the bowl. The separated fluid discharges under gravity from the centrifuge vessel.
The separated fluid in a sedimentation centrifuge rotates at high speed. The built-in pump converts the rotational energy into pressure that discharges the separated liquid under pressure.
A filtration centrifuge, as the name suggests, often uses replaceable filtration media. This media replacement adds to labor and material cost.
A solid bowl sedimentation centrifuge uses the amplified force of gravity to separate the liquid from solids. This type of centrifuge does not require replaceable media, thereby saving cost and time.
There are essential differences between the sedimentation and filtration centrifuges in their design. The following are the key differences between these centrifuges.
The moving parts in this section refer to internal moving parts within the centrifuge. The rotating bowl is a standard moving part in all centrifuges.
The filtration type centrifuge typically has an articulated scraper or blade that periodically scrapes the separated solids from the inside surface of the bowl. The scraped solids then fall out from the bowl by gravity.
A rotating scroll within the sedimentation centrifuge bowl pushes out the separated solids. This solids ejection is a continuous process during which the solids eject out from the rotating bowl due to the centrifugal force.
The filtration type centrifuge has a perforated bowl to allow the separation of liquid from solids and let the separated liquid pass through. The size of these perforations determines the separation particle size.
A sedimentation centrifuge has a solid bowl, and therefore, it is also known as a solid bowl centrifuge. The absence of perforations makes the solid bowl centrifuge more durable with long service life.
Certain areas of the centrifuge bowl are prone to erosion due to the contact with moving abrasive particles. The application of erosion-protecting coatings is essential for centrifuge durability.
The solid particles passing through bowl perforations in a filtration centrifuge can wear out the pores expanding the perforation sizes over time. The application of erosion protection to these pores is not always feasible.
The solid scraper or plow in the filtration centrifuge is susceptible to wear. A hard surface coating on the plow edge ensures wear resistance.
The rotating scroll in the sedimentation centrifuge bowl pushes out the solids. The scroll flights are always in contact with the solids and experience erosion wear. The application of erosion-resistant material, such as tungsten carbide, protects the scroll flights from wear.
An industrial centrifuge capacity (throughput) is the volume of fluid the centrifuge can process in a given time. A decanter-type industrial centrifuge can process 5 to 300+ gallons per minute. An industrial disc centrifuge has a capacity range of 1 to 200+ GPM. The actual processing capacity depends on the process fluid and contaminant level.
The following table lists the capacities of popular sedimentation centrifuges.
|Rated Capacity (Water)||Capacity for 180 cSt Oil|
|Alfa Laval MOPX 207||32 GPM||12 GPM|
|Alfa Laval WHPX 513||100 GPM||35 GPM|
|Alfa Laval NX-314||80 GPM||15 GPM|
|Alfa Laval NX-418||172 GPM||40 GPM|
How big is an industrial centrifuge?
The actual size of an industrial centrifuge depends on the type of centrifuge and its capacity. The following table lists the sizes of industrial centrifuges.
|Centrifuge Type||Minimum Size||Maximum Size|
|Filtration Type - Basket Centrifuge||2' x 3' x 2' (H)||6' x 8' x 8' (H)|
|Filtration Type - Peeler Centrifuge||4' x 5' x 6' (H)||8' x 10' x 8' (H)|
|Sedimentation Type - Decanter Centrifuge||2' x 4' x 1.5' (H)||8' x 25' x 10' (H)|
|Sedimentation Type - Disc Stack Centrifuge||2' x 2' x 2' (H)||8' x 8' x 12' (H)|
The cost of an industrial centrifuge is dependent on several factors. The primary factors that determine the cost of industrial centrifuges are as follows.
A small filtration type centrifuge from an established quality manufacturer starts at approximately $30K, while a high capacity unit can cost over $300K.
Remanufactured units typically cost 60% of comparable new filtration centrifuges.
Sedimentation-type centrifuges have a wider range of costs. A small decanter centrifuge starts at around $50K, while the high-capacity decanters cost over $1M.
Industrial centrifuge manufacturers are classified into two types: OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) and Clone or Generic Centrifuge Manufacturers.
The industrial centrifuge OEMs are established brand names that have been designing and manufacturing these separators for 50+ years. These manufacturers produce high-quality, durable centrifuges that are reliable equipment used worldwide.
In addition to being reliable, durable centrifuges, the OEM machines offer spare parts available worldwide.
The following is a list of OEMs in the industrial centrifuge space and their products offered:
|Manufacturer||Country of Origin||Centrifuge Types|
|Alfa Laval||Sweden||Decanter & Disc Stack (Sedimentation Type)|
|GEA / Westfalia||Germany||Decanter & Disc Stack (Sedimentation Type)|
|Flottweg||Germany||Decanter (Sedimentation Type)|
|Hiller||Germany||Decanter (Sedimentation Type)|
|Heinkel||Germany||Basket (Filtration Type)|
Generic or clone centrifuge manufacturers produce copies of OEM centrifuges that are cheaper but not as reliable as the OEM centrifuges.
These clone centrifuges are typically manufactured in Asian countries (China, Turkey, etc.) and have limited lifespans as well as single-source spare parts restrictions.
Read our article 9 Steps to Selecting the Right Industrial Centrifuge for more information.
The smallest industrial centrifuge is an Alfa Laval MAB-102 disc type, continuous process centrifuge. It weighs 100 lbs, has a 1/2 HP motor, and can process about 1 GPM of diesel fuel to remove water and solids.
The largest industrial centrifuge is an Alfa Laval P3 type decanter centrifuge which weighs around 40,000 lbs and is over 30 feet long. This industrial centrifuge is used in the mining industry for ore separation.
Industrial centrifuges are powered by electricity through electric motors. These centrifuges can be modified to operate on hydraulic power for special applications.
Industrial centrifuges generate noise but are not loud as compared to other industrial machinery. For example, an Alfa Laval disc-stack centrifuge has a noise level of a75 dB.
Industrial centrifuges are rotating equipment that needs to be operated and maintained to ensure safety. These centrifuges are inherently safe as long as they are properly monitored and well maintained.
Industrial centrifuges require periodic service for maintenance and in case of operational issues. The actual frequency of service depends on the centrifuge and its application. For example, Alfa Laval recommends intermittent service for its disc stack centrifuges every 2000 operating hours. It is important to consult with the centrifuge manufacturer for the recommended service interval for specific centrifuges.
Industrial centrifuges have a range of RPMs, from 1,000 RPM for large basket centrifuges to over 20,000 RPM for small tubular bowl centrifuges.
The user may change the operating speed of an industrial centrifuge under extraordinary circumstances in close consultation with the centrifuge manufacturer. Each industrial centrifuge has an operating speed limit based on the safe operation of the centrifuge and the limitation of the centrifuge components. The end-user should NEVER operate an industrial centrifuge above the manufacturer's recommended rotational speed. Over speeding a centrifuge is extremely risky and can cause severe damage to equipment and harm the operator from catastrophic failure.
Industrial centrifuge wear is primarily due to the processing of abrasive solids in the process liquid. These solids move relative to specific centrifuge bowl surfaces, causing wear.
Industrial centrifuges find applications in a range of processing and manufacturing industries. See our comprehensive list of centrifuge applications.
Chemical industries use centrifuges to produce coarse and refined chemicals. Sanitary centrifuges find a host of pharmaceutical industry applications, from raw ingredients to finished drugs under hygienic manufacturing processes.
Biotechnology-related companies use disc-stack centrifuges for cell harvesting and reactant recovery methods.
The food industry also has extensive uses for centrifuges. For example, the separation of beer from yeast, orange juice from the pulp, milk from milk-fat, wine from must, and flavor extraction all use centrifuges.
The comparison of industrial centrifuges with filters or similar media-based separation methods is quite common. These centrifuges offer several over conventional static separation technologies.
The following is a list of some of the main advantages of industrial centrifuges.
Industrial centrifuges process the fluid continuously for extended periods. They don’t require the downtime associated with filter media replacement.
Continuous operation translates into higher production volume, which leads to increased efficiency.
In the case of filtration, as the filter media accumulates the solid contaminants, the flow-through area (pores) reduces, which in turn reduces the flow volume.
The frequent replacement of filter media is necessary to get higher flow volumes, and this cycle continues with varying flow rates.
On the other hand, an industrial centrifuge uses mechanical separation to separate and eject the solid contaminants. This purging is a continuous process that allows a centrifuge to process without any reduction in flow rate.
Industrial centrifuges are heavy-duty machines with an expected life expectancy of 30+ years. Unlike filters, which require constant manual servicing (media replacement), centrifuges are self-operating with fully automatic operation.
The automation practically eliminates service-related downtime, which enhances reliability.
Minimize Product Loss:
The flow-through design feature of industrial centrifuges eliminates the need for manual replacement of filtration media.
Therefore, product losses associated with filter or media replacement are not a concern in centrifugation. Minimized product loss leads to higher productivity and profits.
Low Operating Cost:
The only cost of operating an industrial centrifuge is utilities (electricity, water, air). There are no labor or media costs, which are the main costs related to filters.
Based on the above, the cost per gallon of fluid processed with an industrial centrifuge is negligible. This low operating cost helps the centrifuge owners to recuperate the capital cost remarkably sooner than thought.
Industrial centrifuges are some of the most prolific and understated separation equipment. They have applications in almost all processing industries, as described above.
If any fluid(s) is handled in a specific industry, chances are there is a suitable application for an industrial centrifuge.
The information in this article is based on years of experience we have acquired at Dolphin Centrifuge. Please get to know more about us from our About Us page.